|
Unintended Consequences of Preschool
To: National Desk
Contact: Denise
Kanter, Morningstar
Educational Network, 714-633-8074
ORANGE, Calif.,
June 5 /Christian
Newswire/ -- A child’s brain develops very
rapidly during the first five years, so it is no
wonder one might think these years are a great time
for children to start structured schooling. Parents
eagerly drop their children off at preschool hoping
that their child will be reading by age 4 or 5 and
will become polite and social butterflies. But is
institutionalized preschooling producing
well-behaved and academically superior children?
Studies show that preschool attendance is not
producing the results some had hoped for. In May
2006, the Reason Foundation, in its study ‘Is
Universal Preschool Beneficial?’ found while
preschool enrollment increased from 16 to 66 percent
since 1965, preschool attendance has not resulted in
increased student achievement, with U.S. test scores
rising only very slightly since 1970.
Denise Kanter of
Morningstar Educational
Network commented, “It’s not just academic
scores that are not meeting expectations, preschools
are turning out children with serious emotional and
behavioral problems.” In November 2005, the
Universities of Berkeley and Stanford studied 14,000
preschoolers and kindergarteners and found that
children who attended preschool had more social,
emotional and behavioral problems than children who
had stayed home.
Yielding similar
results as the Universities of Berkeley and
Stanford, C.D. Howe Institute released a study in
February 2006 that reviewed 33,000 children who
attended Quebec’s universal preschool program
between 1994 and 2002. The Institute commented,
"Several measures we looked at suggest that children
were worse off in the years following the
introduction of the universal childcare program. We
studied a wide range of measures of child well-being
from anxiety and hyperactivity to social and motor
skills. For almost every measure, we find that the
increased use of childcare was associated with a
decrease in their well-being relative to other
children." The study found that the aggression
scores of the preschoolers increased 24 per cent
after the program was introduced.
In the 1990’s, the
state of Georgia implemented a universal preschool
program at a cost of $1.15 billion only to find that
it did not produce lasting academic gains. Despite
universal preschool, Georgia continues to rank in
the bottom 10 of states for increasing fourth-grade
reading scores from 1992 to 2005.
“There is just too
much research showing the negative effects of
daycare and preschool for the government to be
promoting universal programs. I fear they think it
is a quick-fix to the disaster public schools have
become. Sending young children off to kindergarten
with preschool acquired problems is only going to
make matters for them and schools worse. Our goal is
to turn the tide, and provide parents with the tools
and resources to just say no to institutionalized
daycare and preschool. Parents should be thinking
about how they can nurture their young children at
home. And they should be considering homeschooling,”
Kanter said.
For more
information on preschooling at home and
homeschooling, visit Considering Homeschooling
Ministry at
http://www.consideringhomeschooling.org, a
Christian ministry sponsored by Morningstar
Educational Network, a 501 (c) non-profit
organization dedicated to helping parents discover
the blessings of homeschooling their children. |